by Robert Sullivan
Okay, you've chosen your business. What next? No doubt, one
of the most asked questions by the prospective business owner is
"Should I incorporate?" To answer this question, we
need to examine what the options are and their respective
advantages and disadvantages. So as not to keep you in suspense,
it should be noted that most new small businesses will not
incorporate - but will operate as a sole proprietorship.
Actually, you have three basic business structures from which to
choose:
1. Sole proprietorship
2. Partnership (limited or general)
3. Corporation (S, C or LLC)
The legal structure you choose depends on a number of things,
including your type of business, individual situation, goals for
the business, and a number of other personal and financial
factors. Before deciding what's best for you, discuss your plans
with your accountant and attorney. Make sure you are prepared to
describe your business plans in some detail. It will be money
and time well spent. Making the right choice can help you avoid
a mistake that can cost you big in terms of possible future
liability.
Before you have any discussions with your professional
advisors, it is useful to understand the basics of the various
legal structures available to you ... sole proprietorship,
partnership, and various forms of corporations.
Sole Proprietorship
This is the most popular form of small business and, as the
name implies, ownership is totally vested with one person. It is
the easiest to establish since no legal formalities are
necessary. The only business requirement may be a license from
your local jurisdiction to allow you to conduct the type of
business you are planning. For example, you may need a license
to sell food to the public.
Sole Proprietorship Advantages:
1. Easy and quick and usually the least ex-pensive to
establish.
2. You have total ownership and control of the business.
3. All the profits of the business belong to you, the owner.
4. No additional Federal taxation on business profits (No
double taxation).
5. No periodic business reporting to the IRS or other
government agency is required.
6. Income tax filing is simply part of your annual personal
tax return (Schedule C).
Sole Proprietorship Disadvantages:
1. The owner is personally liable for all business debts and
the liability is not limited to the value of the business. You
are personally liable for any and all business debt you incur.
2. It is generally more difficult to borrow money or obtain
outside investment than with other types of legal structures.
3. If the owner is incapacitated for any reason, the business
is likely to fail.
4. All management responsibility is with the owner which can
be a heavy burden.
Important Note
A "home business" is frequently a sole
proprietorship and offers a number of unique ad-vantages.
However, just because you are con-ducting business from your
home does not exempt you from possible legal or other
liabilities.
Partnership
This type of business is just what the name implies:
Business ownership is divided between two (or more) partners.
The general partnership is the most common and is formed to
conduct a business with two or more partners being fully
involved in the operation of the business. All the partners
share both profits and liabilities. A limited partner-ship, as
the name implies, provides for limited liability of the
partners. (This liability can be no greater than the partner's
investment in the partnership). In a limited partnership there
must be a least one general partner who remains liable for all
the debts of the partnership.
Forming a partnership is complex and legal advice is very
important. The kind of partnership and the type of partner you
will be determines your potential personal liability.
Partnership Advantages:
1. Synergy as a result of pooling partners' different areas
of expertise.
2. The partnership does not pay Federal in-come taxes. An
informational tax return (IRS Form 1065) must be filed which
shows the pass-through of income/loss to each partner.
3. Liability may be spread among the partners.
4. Investment can come from the partners in the form of a
loan which creates interest income for the partners and a
business deduction for the partnership.
Partnership Disadvantages:
1. Formation and subsequent changes in structure are
complex.
2. Problems with partner(s) as the result of
misunderstandings, different goals, etc., can weaken or destroy
the partnership.
3. Limited partners are liable for debt if they are active
managers in the business. General partners have unlimited
liability. You may also be liable for the commitments of your
partners.
Corporation
There are three major types of corporations, the
C-corporation ("regular corporation"), the
S-corporation (or "S-Corp"), and the Limited Liability
Corporation (or "LLC"). All of these forms of the
corporation are complex legal entities. Their detailed structure
may vary from state to state (incorporating a business in a
given state allows you to conduct business only in that state).
It is essential for you to obtain legal advice if you are
thinking about forming a corporation. Since each state has its
own set of corporation laws, you should contact the appropriate
state office in your state (usually the office of the Secretary
of State) for additional material and procedures. Most offices
can provide a guide for new businesses to follow for
incorporation and doing business in their state. Call or write
for a copy.
Most people immediately think of incorporating in order to
minimize their personal liability. Indeed, the liability of
stockholders (owners) in a corporation is limited under certain
and complex conditions. Today, with the Tax Reform Act of 1986
and other legislation, there are really few good tax reasons to
incorporate (with the exception of dividing corporate profits as
noted below). The best reason for incorporating is, in fact, the
limited liability. However, there is no such thing as total
insulation from liability resulting from doing business as a
corporation.
Record keeping and tax matters with a corporation are
difficult and time-consuming tasks usually requiring the
services of an accountant. You need to keep this in mind when
considering operating costs for your business.
Avoid the "do it yourself" incorporation guides.
Incorporating is a complex process and you should not take on
the task yourself. You cannot afford any mistakes at this point
in your new business, so if you decide incorporation is for you,
do it right and spend the money required to have it done
professionally. Legal fees for setting up a corporation can run
between $350 and $1,500 (assuming it is relatively
straightforward).
Regular Corporation
The corporation is a taxable entity and, as such, pays
taxes. This results in the "double taxation" you may
have heard about. The corporation pays corporate taxes on its
profits, and then, you the owner (shareholder), pay personal
taxes on the dividends your corporation pays you. (The dividends
are not deductible by the corporation). This is one of the
biggest disadvantages of a corporation.
On the other hand, incorporating your business usually makes
it easier to establish credit with suppliers and borrow from
banks. If you expect to use outside investors for business
capital, a corporation is a must.
Regular Corporation Advantages:
1. Shareholders (the owners) enjoy personal limited
liability.
2. It is generally easier to obtain business capital than
with other legal structures.
3. Profits may be divided among owners and the corporation in
order to reduce taxes by taking advantage of lower tax rates.
4. The corporation does not dissolve upon the death of a
stockholder (owner) or if ownership changes.
5. Favorable tax treatment for employee fringe benefits
including medical, disability, and life insurance plans.
6. 70% of any dividends received by the corporation from
stock investments are deductible (unless you purchased the stock
with borrowed money).
Regular Corporation Disadvantages:
1. More expensive and complex to set up than other legal
structures.
2. Completing tax returns usually requires the help of an
accountant.
3. Double taxation on profits paid to owners (corporation
pays corporate taxes on profits and owner pays personal taxes on
dividends from the corporation).
4. Recurring annual corporate fees.
5. Tax rates are higher than individual rates for profits
greater than approximately $75,000.
6. 28% accumulated earnings tax on profits in excess of
$250,000.
7. Business losses are not deductible by the corporation.
S-Corporation
The S-corporation offers the limited liability advantages of
a corporation but does NOT pay Federal taxes. All the earnings
and losses of an S-corporation are passed through to the
share-holders. It is a popular form of incorporation in the
startup years of a business but there are some subtle
disadvantages that need to be taken into account as you grow.
Again, because of the complexities involved, talk with your
attorney and accountant.
S-Corporation Advantages:
1. Owners enjoy personal limited liability as in a regular
corporation.
2. No Federal income tax liability, and in most cases, no
state income tax.
3. Profit/losses are passed to owners ... no double taxation.
4. The S-corporation does not dissolve if one of the owners
dies or otherwise leaves (like a regular corporation).
5. Wholly owned subsidiaries are permitted.
S-Corporation Disadvantages:
1. Legal assistance is required to set up.
2. Maximum of 75 shareholders.
3. Only one class of common stock is permitted (no preferred
stock).
Limited Liability Corporation (LLC)
This type of corporation blends the tax advantages of a
partnership and the limited liability advantages of a
corporation. Owners of an LLC are referred to as
"members." As you might expect, it also has some
limitations but is definitely worth considering. Ask about the
LLC when you contact your appropriate state office for
incorporation information as suggested earlier in the chapter.
LLC Advantages:
1. Limited personal liability for the owners (like a
corporation and unlike a partnership).
2. No Federal taxes (like a partnership).
3. No limit on the number of stockholders (unlike an
S-corporation).
4. More than one class of stock is permitted (unlike an
S-corporation).
5. Business losses may be deducted on your personal tax
return (like a S-corporation).
LLC Disadvantages:
1. Legal assistance is required to set up. The paperwork is
complex.
2. No "continuity of life" as in a regular
corporation. The LLC dissolves if one of the owners dies or
otherwise leaves. However, other formal agreements between the
owners can overcome this.
3. Some states require than an LLC have more than one member.
Making Your Choice
It is difficult to give specific advice as to the choice of
legal business structure since every situation will be unique.
The ad-vantages and disadvantages noted above should be assessed
based on your particular situation. In any case, it is important
to discuss your plans with advisors including both an attorney
and an accountant prior to making your final decision. The
various tax consequences for corporations and partnerships are
complex and must be carefully considered for each specific
situation.
Robert Sullivan is the author of The Small Business Start-Up
Guide, and United States Government - New Customer! He
frequently lectures on starting small businesses and is a guest
on CNBC and NPR as a small business expert. His books may be
ordered toll-free by calling 1 800 375 8439. Visit "The
Small Business Advisor" at http://www.isquare.com